Satellite photo of house with watershed diagram showing how brush clearing causes erosion control issues. Yellow circles, Red zone, and Blue arrows.

Damage of Regular Brush Clearing

Landscapers and contractors don't know the basics of brush clearing, at least not in holistic land management. Do you make these mistakes clearing brush that cause erosion?

The neighbor made an opportunity resource available to me by clear-cutting the area between our homes. Yet they also made a big problem that requires erosion control on slopes.

Bamboo, young poplar, scrub pines, and ivy were nuisances to them.  Within this still stands large oak, hickory, and birch.  Yet these plants were essential to erosion control.

As the image in red outlines, this hill is about a 30-degree slope heavily eroded.

Satellite photo of house with watershed diagram showing how brush clearing causes erosion control issues. Yellow circles, Red zone, and Blue arrows.
How the neighbors brush clearing in yellow and red zones causes watershed blue arrows that creates erosion

How Brush Clearing The Wrong Way Impacts Soil Health and Causes Erosion

They didn't understand how the young brush held back the hill, minimizing damage as these trees repaired surface soil.  It's understandable but worse; their contractor didn't know any better either, doing only half a job.  

All the brush and bamboo were cut off at the ground and then thrown into the woods.

I say “Opportunity resource” because it allowed me to do multiple things.

  1. To prepare a demonstration area for hill remediation and erosion control,
  2. Provide a clearing for several small ponds to catch drain runoff and
  3. Bamboo stalks to propagate in the nursery.  

To learn details on how to do this, get on the waiting list for the next “Erosion Control Methods” class — contact us.  Meanwhile, I'll cover some highlights below.

A single tree standing in the middle of tree brush after a forestry activity. White haze to picture.
Small Trees Avoiding the Destruction of Bulldozers in Tasmania Australia Source Matt Palmer UnSplash

What A Permaculture Design Consultant Knows About Ecology That Your Landscaper Does Not

It is important to clear brush but keep soil structure intact to reduce slope erosion. Using a bulldozer or backhoe exposes soil. This isn't good, especially in a watershed.

Here's what's essential for the Permaculture Designer …

  1. The contractor missed out on the most profitable part of the job.  Brush clearing is just a fraction of the overall job.  When I asked my neighbor if she preferred wildflowers or grass on the hill, she smiled and said both.  Even she knew the job wasn't done.  This job could have been sold as a beautiful meadow at a premium.
  2. Commercial methods of running in heavy equipment make a mess.  I heard the brush cutters and chainsaws earlier today but was working with a client, so I didn't see what was happening.  It cost them fuel and equipment, yet it still looks like garbage.  And it will look worse later if not properly remediated.
  3. Left behind a lot of valuable resources.  Erosion control could have been as easy as geotextile with on-contour faggots.  Best of all, most of the materials they would need came down with the cut.  With a billhook, I processed all the brush in under 45 minutes; tomorrow, I'll bundle and lay in shallow swales before seeding.
  4. No erosion management was provided.  A simple upsell of erosion control plus over-seeding would maintain the hill's integrity, reduce runoff, and make it look great.  Any novice could look at this hill to see past erosion problems.  This particular neighbor pays yearly to have the area above it seeded and to clear this patch every two years.  It's bad management, and now they know better.

You can see how the whole job was designed in a project plan (Plan #LB19) I'm putting together around this project.  Details are unavailable now but stay tuned for a complete treatment.  

Plus, I'll outline inputs and outputs to show you how plentiful this particular means of processing can be.  Frankly, I'm already happy with the 19 bamboo segments and 15 live pegs, and now that hill is cleared for your benefit.

author avatar
Justin Hitt Permaculture Design Consultant
If you want to get more from your small farm, homestead, or estate, ... Justin Hitt is a Permaculture Design Consultant with more than two decades of experience with organic gardening. He teaches the practical application of critical thinking, entrepreneurial ecology, and homestead management. Practical insights for practitioners, estate owners, and homesteaders.
Scroll to Top